It started with the fog — a thick, suffocating wall of it that crept into Halewood just before noon on a late October day. At first, it drifted in innocently enough, soft and light, the kind of mist that curled along the streets on cool mornings. But by the time the church bells chimed noon, it had thickened into something unnatural.
It wasn’t just dense — it was heavy, almost alive, moving in ways it shouldn’t. It billowed against the wind, pushing forward with intent, wrapping around streetlamps and power lines as if tasting them. The sun faded behind its mass, a dim orange disk straining through the grey.
Sarah Holt stood at her kitchen window, her hands submerged in soapy dishwater, watching the fog curl along the ground. It pressed against her windowpane, swirling in lazy, deliberate circles. She leaned closer, frowning. The way it moved unsettled her — not random like normal fog, but slow, rhythmic as if it had breath.
Her dog, Jasper, began to whine from the living room, his ears pinned back, tail tucked between his legs. He stared at the window too, growling low, a sound Sarah had never heard from him before.
She wiped her hands on a dish towel, feeling the unease settle in her chest like a stone. The fog had reached her front porch now, pooling against the door like floodwater. It wasn’t dissipating — if anything, it grew thicker, swallowing the houses across the street until they vanished completely.
Then came the silence.
It was gradual, like the volume of the world being dialed down. First, the birds stopped singing. Then the distant hum of traffic faded. Even the wind died, the leaves on the trees outside hanging still as if time had frozen. Sarah strained her ears, but there was nothing — not even the buzz of her refrigerator.
She reached for her phone, intending to call her neighbor, but the screen was dead. No signal, no Wi-Fi.
Jasper whimpered again, pawing at her leg. Sarah bent down to comfort him, her hands trembling slightly, though she couldn’t explain why. It was just fog. Wasn’t it?
The hours passed in a haze. The fog grew darker as the sun dipped lower, the daylight fading far too quickly. Sarah kept the lights on, but they seemed weaker, the bulbs flickering as if struggling against some unseen force.
By evening, the fog had fully encased the house. She could no longer see her front yard. It felt like being submerged underwater, cut off from the surface.
That was when she noticed it.
Footprints.
Outside her window, in the fog, faint impressions appeared on the grass — one by one, leading from the road to her porch. There was no figure to make them, no shadowed outline. Just the prints, sinking into the earth as if pressed by invisible feet.
Sarah backed away from the window, her breath catching in her throat. Jasper barked sharply, the sound loud in the otherwise suffocating quiet.
The footsteps stopped at her front door.
A soft knock followed—three slow, deliberate taps.
Sarah didn’t move. Her heart pounded so hard she could feel it in her fingertips. Whoever — whatever — was out there didn’t knock again.
Minutes passed. Maybe hours.
Eventually, she worked up the courage to look outside again. The fog was still there, thicker than ever, but the footprints were gone.
And so was her neighbor’s house.
Where the Lornes’ house had stood that morning was now just a flat expanse of grass, untouched, like nothing had ever been built there. No rubble, no debris. Just…gone.
Sarah clutched Jasper to her chest, sinking to the floor. She wanted to believe she was dreaming, that any moment she’d wake up. But the sharp sting of her nails digging into her palms told her this was real.
She wasn’t the only one trapped.
Across town, others noticed the same — houses missing, streets ending in blank fields where they shouldn’t. People were vanishing, entire families. One by one.
No screams. No signs of struggle.
Just gone.
And the fog kept creeping forward, hungry and silent.
When the fog finally retreated on the morning of the fourth day, it left behind a hollow, broken shell of Halewood. The streets, once lined with neat rows of houses and trimmed hedges, were now a disjointed labyrinth — entire blocks gone, patches of empty land where homes and buildings had once stood. It was as if the fog had erased them, not with violence, but with terrifying precision, like a hand wiping clean a chalkboard.
Sarah Holt wandered out of her house, Jasper glued to her side, both of them gaunt and hollow-eyed. Her clothes clung to her skin, damp from days of fog seeping through the cracks in her walls. She wasn’t sure why she had survived — or if she had. The air felt different now, thinner, almost brittle.
A handful of other survivors emerged too, scattered figures stepping out into the ghost town. They moved slowly, cautiously, like deer after a storm, unsure if the danger had truly passed.
Sarah recognized some of them — Maggie Lorne, the town’s librarian, her hair tangled and wild; Patrick Wilde, who worked at the gas station, limping as though something inside him had snapped; Liam Strauss, the high school janitor, clutching a rusted crowbar in his shaking hands.
They didn’t speak at first. Words felt too fragile, too human, after what they had seen.
But then they gathered, drawn to the church in the center of town — St. Jude’s, its spire rising defiantly into the washed-out sky. It was there that Sarah saw it: the note.
A single sheet of yellowed paper was nailed to the wooden church doors, flapping gently in the breeze. The others stopped behind her as she stepped forward, drawn to it by something deeper than curiosity — a cold, sinking dread.
The handwriting was neat, almost elegant, but there was something unnatural about it. The letters curled too perfectly, the ink too dark, as though it had been written by something that had studied human hands but didn’t fully understand them.
The list was short:
Sarah Holt
Daniel Keene
Maggie Lorne
Patrick Wilde
Liam Strauss
The names stared back at them, black ink seeping into the paper-like veins.
“Where’s Daniel?” Maggie asked, her voice cracking the silence.
No one answered.
They found him later that day.
Daniel Keene, the town’s mechanic, had holed up in his shop when the fog came. He’d left a message scratched into the wall with a wrench — “I hear them outside. In the fog. Don’t open the door.”
But something had.
His body was in the bathtub, but it didn’t make sense. The tub was dry, dusty even, but Daniel looked as if he had been submerged for hours — bloated, his skin pale and puckered, waterlogged. His mouth hung open as if gasping for air that had never come.
There was no water in the house. No signs of a struggle.
Only the list.
The survivors gathered again at the church, fear sharpening into something uglier — suspicion.
“Why us?” Patrick muttered, his eyes darting between the remaining four names. “Why are we on it?”
No one had an answer.
But the more Sarah thought about it, the more a terrible thought gnawed at her. It wasn’t random. It couldn’t be.
She racked her memory, trying to stitch together any connection between them, but nothing fit. They weren’t close friends. They hadn’t grown up together. She hadn’t spoken to Liam Strauss in years, and she’d only nodded at Maggie in the library on occasion.
But still, something about the list felt personal.
That night, Sarah sat in her living room, the note spread across her coffee table. Jasper slept curled at her feet, twitching in uneasy dreams. The house was too quiet, the kind of silence that felt full — like something else was listening.
Her eyes kept drifting to the list. She noticed it then — the faintest indentation at the bottom of the paper as if someone had pressed too hard while writing. A single word, nearly invisible:
“Why?”
It made her skin crawl.
A memory bubbled up — vague, fractured. Years ago, a night she’d buried deep. A mistake she’d sworn to forget. But the details slipped through her mind like water through a sieve.
Had they all done something? Shared a secret?
The thought clung to her as the darkness deepened outside.
The fog was gone, but the danger wasn’t.
The list wasn’t a warning. It was a death sentence — one that had already begun.
The fog had retreated, but Halewood was far from safe. In the days following Daniel Keene’s death, the survivors drifted through the hollowed-out town, their eyes haunted, their steps uncertain. Streets that had once been familiar were now warped, subtly wrong — alleyways stretched longer than they should, houses leaned at crooked angles, and windows reflected strange things when no one was looking.
But it was the mirrors that changed first. Sarah noticed it on the second morning after Daniel’s death. She stood in her bathroom, brushing her teeth, staring into the cracked mirror above the sink. At first, nothing seemed off. But then her reflection blinked — a half-second too late. It was barely noticeable, but enough to freeze her mid-motion, toothbrush still in her mouth.
She squinted, moving her head from side to side. Her reflection copied her movements, but there was a delay, a sluggishness, as though it were underwater. Her heart thudded in her chest, heavy and loud in the silence.
She stepped back. The reflection smiled.
Sarah spun away from the mirror, bile rising in her throat. Jasper, her dog, barked sharply from the hallway, his hackles raised, teeth bared at the bathroom door. Sarah slammed the medicine cabinet shut, the mirror now facing inward, but she couldn’t shake the feeling of being watched — of something inside the glass, waiting.
She wasn’t the only one.
Maggie Lorne had smashed every mirror in her house by that afternoon. Sarah found her in the living room, sitting cross-legged in a mess of broken glass, her hands bleeding from the effort.
“They’re not us,” Maggie whispered, cradling her hands as blood dripped onto her lap. “They’re watching from the other side.”
Sarah wanted to dismiss it, but deep down, she knew Maggie was right.
It got worse that night.
Sarah woke to the sound of Jasper growling, low and guttural. Her bedroom was dark, the curtains drawn, but moonlight filtered in through the gaps. Jasper stood at the foot of the bed, his gaze fixed on the full-length mirror in the corner.
Sarah sat up slowly. The mirror was fogged, as though someone had been breathing on the other side. And then, a handprint appeared — five long fingers splayed against the glass, the print too large to be human.
She didn’t move. Her reflection was there too, but it wasn’t mimicking her. It stood still, its head tilted to the side, its mouth stretched into a grin far too wide.
The handprint on the glass began to press harder, the mirror creaking under the pressure, cracks forming like spiderwebs across its surface.
Sarah grabbed Jasper and fled the room, slamming the door shut behind her.
The next morning, she went to find Maggie — but Maggie was gone.
Sarah, Patrick, and Liam found her house eerily silent. The broken mirrors still littered the floors, glass crunching beneath their feet as they moved through the rooms.
They found Maggie in the living room — or what was left of her.
Her body lay sprawled on the floor, eyes open wide, mouth twisted in a silent scream. But the reflection in the cracked mirror above the fireplace still moved.
Maggie’s reflection stood upright in the glass, looking down at her lifeless body, smiling. It placed a delicate hand against the inside of the mirror, tapping once, twice, as if trying to get their attention.
Patrick swore under his breath, backing away, but Sarah couldn’t look away.
The list isn’t about who dies, she realized with a cold, sinking horror. It’s about who gets replaced.
The fog hadn’t taken Daniel or Maggie — their reflections had.
And now there were only three names left.
That night, Sarah smashed every mirror in her house. She shattered the windows too, afraid that any reflective surface might act as a doorway. Jasper watched her with wide, trembling eyes, his tail tucked between his legs.
But deep down, she knew it was useless.
The reflections weren’t bound to the glass anymore.
She saw it in the puddles on the street, in the gleam of her doorknob, even in Jasper’s dark, glassy eyes — warped versions of herself, watching, waiting, grinning.
The fog might have receded, but something had crossed over with it.
And it was only a matter of time before they all switched places.
Halewood had become a shell of its former self — empty, brittle, and decaying from within. The streets were no longer safe, not because of the fog, but because of the reflections.
Sarah Holt moved through the town like a ghost, clutching a rusted crowbar in one hand, Jasper pressed to her side, tail low between his legs. Everything around her felt off — wrong in a way she couldn't explain. Buildings sagged unnaturally, as if buckling under an unseen weight, their windows dark and hollow. Streetlamps leaned at crooked angles, flickering even though the power had long since died.
But it was the people — or what was left of them — that were the worst.
The few remaining survivors weren’t human anymore. They looked the same at first glance, walking slowly through the streets, their heads down, as if lost in thought. But their movements were jerky, unnatural, like puppets held up by invisible strings.
And their eyes — that was the giveaway.
Hollow. Completely black, like empty pits, reflecting nothing.
Sarah had passed one of them that morning — an old woman she vaguely remembered from the market. The woman’s head had snapped up as Sarah walked by, and for a split second, their gazes met. No life, no spark. Just those gaping voids where her eyes should have been.
Sarah didn’t look back.
She didn’t know if they could see her or were simply wandering, waiting for something. But instinct told her not to draw attention.
She made her way toward the outskirts of Halewood, hoping to find some kind of escape, but the roads ended in nothingness. Where there had once been highways and dirt paths, there were now only open fields — smooth, unblemished land, as if the world had been sanded down to the bone.
There was no way out.
That night, Sarah returned to her house — or what remained of it. The walls were buckling inward, warped, and twisted. The mirrors she had smashed earlier were gone. In their place, smooth sheets of dark glass covered the walls, ceiling, and even the floors — seamless, like a black pool of liquid hardened into form.
She tried not to look at them, but it was impossible. Every surface reflected her back, but not as she was. Her reflection was thinner, her skin pale and stretched tight over her bones. Its smile was wrong — too wide, too eager. And it moved before she did, leading her, guiding her through her own house.
Sarah clutched the crowbar tighter, breathing heavily. Jasper whimpered behind her, refusing to enter the room.
In the living room, she found something new — a large, ornate mirror she didn’t recognize, standing tall in the center of the room like a doorway. The glass was fogged, swirling with dark mist.
And then, a face appeared.
It was hers.
But this version of her was calm, almost serene. The reflection pressed its hands against the inside of the glass, tilting its head, studying Sarah with something like pity.
Sarah backed away, but the reflection spoke — though no sound came from its mouth. The words formed directly in her mind, cold and sharp.
"You don’t belong here."
She gasped, clutching her head as pain shot through her temples. The reflection smiled.
"You never did."
Images flooded her mind — memories she couldn’t place. A small house in the woods, a man’s face blurred beyond recognition, a dark ritual performed under a moonless sky. She remembered chanting words she didn’t understand, desperate to forget something terrible, something unforgivable.
The fog. The reflections. The list.
This was her fault.
Somehow, years ago, Sarah had called this darkness here — a bargain made, a debt left unpaid. She had buried the memories so deeply that even she had forgotten. But the fog hadn’t. It had come back to collect.
The reflection’s smile widened as Sarah sank to her knees, tears streaking her face.
Outside, the hollow-eyed survivors gathered, surrounding her house. Dozens of them, maybe hundreds, their faces blank, their eyes empty. They stared at the house, at the mirror inside, as if waiting for something — or someone.
Sarah stood slowly, her reflection still watching her.
“Why?” she whispered, though she knew it wouldn’t answer.
The reflection’s grin faltered for the briefest moment, and then it stepped backward into the swirling fog beyond the glass, vanishing into the dark.
The ornate mirror cracked down the center, the sound sharp and final.
But the reflections in the walls around her remained — dozens of them now, all versions of herself, all watching.
Sarah realized the truth too late.
The fog hadn’t come to take her. It had come to replace her.
And there was nothing left to stop it.
The fog returned at dawn, thicker and darker than before, wrapping Halewood in its suffocating embrace. It poured down the streets like smoke, creeping into every crevice, swallowing the last remains of the town. Where buildings once stood, only jagged silhouettes loomed, like bones jutting from the earth.
Inside her crumbling house, Sarah sat motionless on the living room floor, staring at the fractured mirror in front of her — the ornate one that had appeared days ago, now split down the center.
The house groaned around her, its walls bending inward as if the structure itself was breathing — inhaling her, swallowing her whole. Jasper whimpered beside her, his small body trembling with fear, but even he had grown weaker, and quieter, as though the fog had begun to drain him too.
The reflections in the darkened walls still moved, though Sarah no longer mirrored them. They had lives of their own now — hollow-eyed versions of herself pacing, smiling, whispering words she couldn’t hear.
The air felt heavy, pressing down on her chest, making it difficult to breathe. It wasn’t just fear anymore — it was inevitability.
Then came the sound again.
The soft pattern of footsteps upstairs. Slow, deliberate, dragging.
Sarah clenched the crowbar in her hands, but it felt useless now, a flimsy piece of metal against something far older, far stronger.
The footsteps reached the top of the stairs.
She didn’t look. She couldn’t.
A soft knock echoed from the living room mirror — three slow taps, identical to the ones she’d heard on her front door days ago.
Sarah swallowed hard, her throat dry and raw. She turned to the mirror.
Her reflection was there, but it wasn’t mimicking her. It stood straight, calm, clean — untouched by the horrors Sarah had endured. Its face was serene, lips curled into a gentle, almost sympathetic smile.
Then it spoke.
No sound filled the room, but the words echoed inside her skull, cold and sharp.
"Why no?"
Sarah’s heart clenched.
“Why no what?” she whispered aloud, her voice thin and weak.
The reflection tilted its head, as if studying her, before lifting one pale hand and placing it against the glass.
"You were given a choice," it said.
Memories surged up, drowning her — the ritual from years ago, standing in the woods beneath a moonless sky, the feel of cold earth beneath her feet. She had been desperate, broken. There had been voices — whispers offering her a chance to forget, to erase the guilt that had gnawed at her for years.
But there had been a price. One simple question.
"Do you accept?"
And she had said no.
She hadn’t accepted the full bargain, but the act itself had opened the door — a crack wide enough for something to slip through. She thought rejecting it had saved her, but it had only delayed the inevitable.
"The debt is due," the reflection said, its voice softer now.
The walls around her groaned louder, the floorboards beneath her feet splintering. Jasper barked weakly, collapsing onto his side.
Tears filled Sarah’s eyes. “Why me? Why this?”
But the reflection only smiled.
"Because you asked to forget. And now, you remember."
The mirror rippled like water, and the reflection stepped forward — out of the glass, into the room. It was her, but perfect — unscarred, unbroken.
Sarah scrambled backward, but there was nowhere left to go. The walls were folding inward, the ceiling cracking apart.
The other reflections in the walls followed, stepping out one by one. Dozens of Sarahs, each with hollow smiles, surrounded her.
The perfect version — the first — knelt beside her.
"Let go," it whispered.
Sarah felt the crowbar slip from her hands, her strength draining. Her body was cold, her vision blurring as the fog seeped into her lungs.
She closed her eyes.
Her last thought echoed in her mind, fragile and broken.
Why no?
The world went still.
When Sarah opened her eyes, she was standing in the center of the living room. The house was pristine — the walls intact, the windows clear, sunlight pouring in. Jasper sat at her feet, wagging his tail.
But something was wrong.
She turned toward the ornate mirror.
Her reflection was still there — but it wasn’t moving. It sat slumped on the floor, lifeless, its eyes wide in terror, its mouth open mid-scream.
Sarah — or what had become her — smiled at the sight, tilting her head as though admiring a painting. She reached down to pet Jasper, who nuzzled against her without hesitation.
Outside, the fog had cleared. The streets looked normal again — houses standing tall, trees swaying gently in the breeze.
But Halewood wasn’t Halewood anymore.
It was hollow.
Every window reflected faces that didn’t quite belong — twisted smiles, too-wide eyes, something wrong in their movements.
And Sarah, standing in her perfect new skin, stepped outside, blending in with the rest.
The town was alive again — but filled with copies.
The originals were trapped, forgotten, their screams echoing only behind the glass.
And somewhere, deep beneath the fog, the question still lingered, unanswered.
Why no? ….
THE END
📜 Copyright Notice & Caution to Readers 📜
© 2025 Abrar Nayeem Chowdhury. All Rights Reserved.
This Story, "Why NO?", including its title, storyline, characters, settings, dialogues, and original content, is protected under the United States Copyright Act (Title 17, U.S. Code) and international copyright laws.
⚠️ Unauthorized Use is Strictly Prohibited
Any unauthorized copying, reproduction, distribution, adaptation, or resale of this work, whether in print, digital, audio, or film format, without written permission from the author/publishe,r is strictly prohibited and may result in legal action under U.S. copyright law and DMCA (Digital Millennium Copyright Act) provisions.
⚠️ No AI, Fanfiction, or Commercial Use Without Permission
- This work may not be used for AI training, machine learning datasets, or automated text generation without express written consent from the copyright holder.
- Creating derivative works, including fanfiction, adaptations, scripts, or spin-offs, requires legal authorization.
- Commercial use, including paid promotions, film rights, merchandising, or translations, is strictly prohibited without a licensing agreement.
📩 For Permissions & Licensing
For inquiries regarding film rights, adaptations, audiobook production, or other permissions, contact:
📧 motivationbeast74@gmail.com
⚠️ Plagiarism is a Crime. Respect Intellectual Property.
Thank you for supporting original storytelling. 🙌📖🔥
Comments
Post a Comment